People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Went out to dinner here with my family. I ordered a cheese and sausage pizza. Definitely one of the best ones I've ever had. Our waitress was very friendly and did a great job with our large group. ”
“ Ordered the 14" cheese pizza with pepperoni, sausage and bacon. When it arrived I was in disbelief, this thing was not 14", it was closer to 16! The thin crispy crust and pizza sauce they use made this the best pizza I have ever had. I ate the whole thing with 2 pints of spotted cow, which made a great combination. As a first time customer, if I'm ever back in the area I will be visiting again. ”
“ Friday night Fish fry with Mom Week somewhere between 30 and 40. Nonna's Pizzeria and Bar. I didn't realize that they did a fish fry until a long time customer told me I had to go. (Thank you Gretchen). A different variety of fish with choice of fries, tater tots, onion rings and a whole bunch of other stuff. On top of getting way more fish than I could eat it came with soup. Nice size pieces of fish that were light and flaky. Very busy, but the staff was super nice and friendly. Taylor was our bartender and she was great. Overall a fantastic experience with great food. If you haven't tried Nonna's Pizzeria and Bar you should. ”
“ First time ordering from Nonnas in Sturtevant. Picked up a large pepperoni and sausage. Looks like I received half pepperoni, half sausage, not what I wanted but I’ll clarify next time. It’s Sunday and it was busy as to be expected. Kind of skimpy on the sausage, I guess I’ll ask for double the meat next time... Really nice thin crust though and it taste really good so I’ll order from here again. 35 - 40 minute pick up time, did not have wait long to get my order. Plenty of parking and the dining area seemed pretty nice. ”
“ I have only ordered pizza because it is delicious thin and crispy crust pizza. Quality cheese and toppings. Give Nonna's a try, you will be happy you did. I wish they were closer to my house. Update.... I haven't been to Nonna's in a while but today I had a thin crust pizza for lunch and it was delicious. Keep up the good work. 10/5/24: Had dinner here last night and it was delicious. Add a large cheese and ground beef thin crust pizza. Also had a dinner salad. The crust is nice and crispy. The sauce is absolutely delicious. I highly recommend coming to Nonna's Pizza. ”
“ Great staff and delicious food. The food does taste authentic ”
“ First, the hostess happily seated our group of 7 including a wheelchair even though we hadn't thought to make a reservation. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive even as she got busier. Our group had pizza, of course, mushroom ravioli, and chicken pesto pasta. They were all delicious! At the end of the visit, one of us lost his phone in the parking lot. They went above and beyond to help reunite them and didn't accept a monetary thank you. A great group of people and great food!! Thank you!! ”
“ Our names are Samantha and Brian. We are semi truck drivers and Nonna's Pizzeria & Pub is by far the best pizza we have ever had . The crust and homemade sauce was absolutely phenomenal. Very clean and friendly staff. Thank you so much you guys we enjoyed our visit. ”
Menu
Antipasto Salad
Chicken Parmesan
Cheese
Bbq Chicken
Buffalo Chicken
About
Nonna’s Pizzeria and Pub
Welcome to Nonna’s Pizzeria and Pub, a delightful culinary gem nestled at 8607 Durand Ave, Sturtevant, Wisconsin. Renowned for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional food, Nonna's encapsulates the warmth of family dining with a menu that is sure to tantalize your taste buds.
One of the standout features at Nonna's is their legendary thin and crispy crust pizza, crafted with high-quality cheese and a delectable array of toppings. Diners rave about the cheese and sausage favorite, with many calling it one of the best they've ever tasted. Customer reviews highlight the pizza's generous size, with some claiming their 14-inch pie felt more like 16 inches—an impressive feat for a casual eatery.
The menu doesn't just stop at pizza, though. Nonna’s also offers a fantastic Friday night fish fry that has locals buzzing. Patrons adore the variety of fish served alongside hearty sides like fries, onion rings, and tater tots. Each piece of fish is described as light and flaky, promising a satisfying meal for seafood lovers.
The atmosphere at Nonna’s is vibrant yet cozy, making it an ideal spot for family dinners or casual gatherings. Customers consistently mention the attentive and friendly staff, who enhance the dining experience. Whether it's a large group or a simple takeout order, the service remains prompt and courteous.
Your next visit to Nonna's could be filled with delicious discoveries, like the perfect pairing of a hot pizza and a refreshing pint of local beer. One satisfied customer even shared that their visit was complemented perfectly by a couple of pints of Spotted Cow—an impressive duo that might just have you planning your next trip for the same reason!
If you're in the Sturtevant area and have yet to experience Nonna’s, the rave reviews from regulars and first-timers alike should inspire you to stop in. With a menu filled with tantalizing options, there’s something for everyone at this beloved pizzeria. So, gather your family and friends, and prepare for a warm welcome and great food at Nonna’s Pizzeria and Pub!
Book a table